A Kind of Spark tells the story of 11-year-old Addie as she campaigns for a memorial in memory of the witch trials that took place in her Scottish hometown. Addie knows there's more to the story of these 'witches', just like there is more to hers. Can Addie challenge how the people in her town see her, and her autism, and make her voice heard?
Reviewed by Ben Harris
Although perspective and ‘what it means to be different’ are both clearly major themes of this book, I should point out first and foremost that this is quite emphatically a superb story. There are so many woven threads to this tale – from Addie’s developing friendship at school, her sister Keedie’s secrets, the campaign to raise the plaque – that the book whip-cracks along with the pages almost turning by themselves right up to the end. The plot is so satisfying, the story told so eloquently, that the reader will reach the end completely spellbound (and, like me, very eager to read more from Elle McNicoll).
But as if this were not enough, the book has a unique and compelling voice. Told in the first person, we explore Addie’s passions and interests, from sharks to the injustice of the witch-trials themselves. In her recent conversation with Lizzie Huxley-Jones for Blackwells Bookshops, Elle McNicoll) (herself autistic) drew attention to the necessity of ‘Own Voice’ writing: books where the author from an under-represented group (relating to ethnicity, sexuality, or disability, for example) writes about their own experiences or from their own perspectives. In A Kind of Spark, we share Addie’s frustrations, excitements, joys, sadnesses; they complement, shape and colour the narrative with true authenticity. We ultimately have not only a great story, but a novel that leaves the reader a different person, appreciating more the diverse ways in which autistic people see the world.
There is also a strong message given about those who choose not to listen to those voices. Miss Murphy is Addie’s teacher; she is also a horrendous character, picking at Addie’s inability to be like the others in the class: I was just appalled at the way she stands over the poor girl at the start of the book, criticizing Addie’s difficulties with handwriting. Keedie, in her turn, faced the wrath of Miss Murphy and the way in which those injustices that were meted out still lives with her ten years on is testament to the indelible frustration caused by prejudice and complete lack of understanding. Elle McNicoll raised the hope in the Blackwells interview that the book, having been read by teachers, might develop the empathy that is needed when working with young autistic people.
I cannot recommend this book enough to teachers and to classes, perfect for Year 5 upwards. Because of the strong voice and the compelling storyline, it would naturally lend itself very well to being read aloud and prompt much wonderful, necessary discussion. I also think that autistic children would feel very much supported by reading and talking about this book too; there is much that will speak directly to them, that will offer them a hand of companionship, and in a gentle, nurturing voice will say to them: ‘I get you. And I’ve got you.’
Show Us Who You Are is the second novel by Elle McNicoll. Reviewed here.